Jump to content
Click here if you are having website access problems ×

5 speed versus 6


Steve Robinson

Recommended Posts

I've now begun the process of hunting for the right car, but the budget is looking tight to say the least. It seems that I won't be able to stretch to a superlight (unless Alan does decide to sell his 46,000 mile superlight which may just scrape inside what I can afford)

 

One of the cheap(er) options is to go for a mega grad but these are all 5 speed boxes. Is this going to be a major drawback in terms of being competitive in class 3 do you think?

 

Your thoughts as always appreciated *thumbup*

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would think the 6 speed would give you an advantage. Only drove my 5 speed on the road and got realy fed up with the ratios. If i had kept it I would have got a close ratio box but this does not save you any money.

 

Keep looking for the right one, if you leave it till the end of the year prices will be down a bit, if you leave it till Feb you may see prices further south.

 

 

go for a 6 speed

 

David

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would also go for a 6 speed and agree with David that if you wait until later in the year I'm sure you will find something that will meet your specification. It is worth keeping in mind that it is cheaper to buy the car with the right spec rather than paying for upgrades later. If you cannot afford a Superlight a good spec Roadsport fitted with either a 1.6 or 1.8 SS K will be just as competitive.

 

Mark D

Su77on Se7ens *cool*

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steve,

I've got a mega Grad, run in class 3 and not on the pace. Have a look at MIRA, Curborough or Llandow results

I run on AO48's med as well which doen't help.

I think you do need the 6 speed box ( or change the ratios in the 5 speed), LSD...oh and ACB10's

 

MikeW

Mega Grad Race No 22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Changing ratios was my other thought. Would it be cheaper to get a 5 and then change the ratios to the same as the first 5 from a 6 speed box?

 

Even with softening prices the budget won't get me a superlight or roadsport with 6 speed, LSD, adjustable dampers and wide track that i would ideally need.

 

I see it as I need to comprimise somewhere to save money, it's just a question of where.

 

Budget for the car is ideally around the £11k to £12k mark.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Area Representative
Would it be cheaper to get a 5 and then change the ratios to the same as the first 5 from a 6 speed box?


 

Steve,

It's not as simple as that! The Caterham ratios are very close in comparison to any of the Quaife/Tran-X ratios, whilst retaining a relatively low 1st gear. the closest alternative box's, have quite a tall 1st gear.

It really is worth hanging on to get a Caterham 6 speed - the ratio's, as you know, suit the K very well!

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steve,

If you are going to compromise then cut out food, housing or other non-essentials 😬

 

I still reckon your best bet is a Roadsport A which will have anything on you need and be a bit cheaper as an ex-racer. Given the guys are running on the back of the R400's this year I would have thought there would be a few for sale later in the season and they should jusy about be in budget.

 

 

MikeW

Mega Grad Race No 22

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I tried a roadsport A this morning and have uncovered a problem with them. It seems they have uprated springs in the gearbox which makes the change much stiffer than the standard box. This is an issue for Sally who will also drive the car.

 

I'm talking to Caterham about their blue and yellow roadsport A that is up for £12,500. They have offered to swap the leather seats for tilletts for the same price which isn't bad and are looking into changing the spring back to a standard road one to make the gearbox easier to use.

 

This could make quite a nice option: for £12.5k I get the 1.6k with supersport, 6 speed box, LSD, wide track and already on ACB10's (unknown compound though). We'll see what they say about the gearbox on Monday when their technicians are back.

 

Steve

 

Edited by - Steve Robinson on 16 Jul 2005 17:14:58

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cheers guys, I'll call Phil tomorrow to see what he says.

 

So what do you reckon to the yellow and blue Roadsport at Caterham (in the used section under race cars)? Looks like a good spec to take sprinting to me, but would you pay 12.5k for it? Personally I don't like the looksm(colours) of it much but am more concerned with it having the right spec than how it looks at this stage.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Its the rigth spec,

colour: if you think the blue is ok, then it would be cheep to spray the yellow wings,and nose either blue or a colour you think will go.

 

if you do not like the blue well then it gets expensive.

 

What history do you know about the car?

has it had a hard life at the front of the pack, was it maintained by the owner or a race team? Any bills to get an idea about how well it was looked after?

 

David

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It's the shade of blue I'm not keen on. Best option I guess would be to re-spray once funds become available at some point in the future.

 

I don't know anything on the history yet, i'm hoping to get down to Caterham to have a look in detail on Thursday. I did go and check out the red with silver stripe roadsport A at Caterham Midlands. That was the one with the ridiculous gearchange.

 

Also a good sprinting spec but it looked quite tired, got the impression it has had a very hard life. The blue and yellow one looks like it has had more TLC from the picture I would say.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When Graham drove Rob's and mine on the same day he said the gearboxs were very diffrent.

 

I have never been happy with mine (it was a replacement one as the original failed *confused*) and most people who have driven it have complained about the poor gear change compared to other 6 speeders...

 

the plan this winter is for it to go to R&R with the diff for a rebuild....

 

rob

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Adrian - it is already road registered, it just doesn't mention it on the website.

 

Caterham have just come back to day that the cost to change springs in the gearbox will be £650 😳 Takes it a bit close to the top end of the budget, but am going to see it Thursday to see if it is worth paying the money for.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Steve

 

R&R charged me £350 to refurb my 6 speed which included replacing 3 synchros and an uprated 5th gear which was over £100 on its own, so if your gearbox already has this £250 should cover it. As Rob says a few beers etc should be sufficient for the labour 😬

 

Mark D

Su77on Se7ens *cool*

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rob- you're sport on. The cost of the spring change is £70, the rest is labour for getting the box/engine in and out.

 

If a couple of technically minded people are willing to help me get the engine and gearbox out and back in for some food/beers/coffee that would be great. I'd be happy to put a slug of what I would have paid CC to NTL as a thankyou.

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

sounds like a plan of sorts then...

 

anyway that might give you time to try the box and see if it is an issue for you or Sally....

 

of course we wouldn't accidently swap it for a rusty type 9 when you weren't looking 😬

 

rob *smile*

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Rob 😬

 

Just thinking what a fantastic club this is. Whilst without a seven people are generous enough to let me compete in theirs, and when I'm trying to get a seven people are happy to come and help me get it sorted *thumbup* *thumbup*

 

Unless of course helping me get a car sorted is the best way to ensure I don't keep nicking your cars next year *tongue* *tongue*

 

Steve

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...